Unlimited PTO is generous in theory, not in practice. Shorter workweeks that cram five days of work into four are burning out employees.
These are just two examples of how today’s “benefits” trick new hires into choosing a company.
TL;DR
- The difference between a 4-day workweek vs. unlimited PTO comes down to how well a company designs the benefit.
- Unlimited PTO’s pros and cons include easier admin but a greater burden on managers.
- Four-day workweeks have “time off” built into the schedule, so workers don’t have to ask.
- Either may make a company more competitive, but culture is still the true driver of employee retention.
Is unlimited PTO a good idea?
The consensus is NO–unless it comes with MTO (minimum or mandatory time off). Surveys often show that employees with unlimited PTO take fewer days off than those with limits. Even when a study finds they take more, it’s only a day or two more than those with a cap.
The reason? Freedom makes them anxious. How many days is too many? Is this a good enough reason to take off?
If someone takes fewer days off than me, and does my job better while I’m out enjoying all of this luxurious PTO, will I even have a job when I get back?
“I think it’s bullshit,” says HeyTaco CEO Doug Dosberg. His experience at another company illustrates this problem. “People were afraid to take vacations because if you weren’t there, somebody else would step in.”
Altogether, unlimited PTO sounds like part of a cool company culture. But without the subtler, more crucial cultural features (norms and habits), it serves little purpose.
| 📢 Is unlimited PTO a trap? It is when employees don’t know what “good” looks like at work. Listen to the full discussion. |
Unlimited PTO: Pros and cons
Larger amounts of paid time off can be an expectation on high-trust teams or in other cultures/locations. But in general, going fully unlimited has specific drawbacks that make it less appealing to today’s workforce.
PRO: It allows life to happen.
Employees with unlimited PTO are in luck if their personal lives demand more of them without warning. Anything from making a hard-to-get appointment to caring for loved ones feels more possible.
CON: People take less time off.
Offering unlimited PTO doesn’t mean your company is PTO-positive. People can grin and bear it through a lot of situations simply because no one else takes days off. Especially leaders.
PRO: Attracts autonomous talent.
Unlimited anything sounds great to people trying to avoid micromanagement at work. They’re told that as long as their responsibilities are completed or covered, they can go ahead and book that trip.
CON: Masks understaffing and unbalanced workloads.
Another reason why people don’t take PTO. When the onus is on the employee to ensure they’re covered while away, it may mean they can never take off. They’re never truly caught up, and no one else can fill their shoes.
PRO: Easier admin.
Fewer areas to watch. HR doesn’t need to calculate or monitor metrics associated with usage.
CON: Too dependent on manager approval.
One employee’s manager denies an employee’s request to take an afternoon off for their child’s sporting event. Another manager at the same company gave their team member three days off to go fishing.
Without limits or guardrails, it’s up to managers to do what they think is best. This can look inconsistent and unfair. It also adds to the risk of manager burnout.
4-day workweek benefits for employees (and employers 😏)
With employees starting to side-eye so-called unlimited PTO, organizations are considering the four-day workweek as a benefit.
Some industries, like customer support, offer this in staggered arrangements or with a rotating extra day off. Many can just get away with striking one day off the calendar, like Friday or Monday. With either model, this is what everyone gets.
Less burnout, more life.
Your first day off is spent recovering from the last week. The second day off is spent preparing for the one ahead. This is how people get trapped in a work-centric cycle that leads to burnout. An extra day lets people restore their energy and fill their cup with what they’d love to be doing if not for work.
Reduced need for PTO.
When employees have a weekday to go to the doctor or the bank, they make fewer requests. This removes anxiety and gives them the actual freedom “unlimited” PTO only teases at.
All killer, no filler focused work.
A survey by the American Psychiatric Association shows that 81% of employees feel they can be just as effective at their jobs working only four days. (Nearly the same number also reported they’d be happier.) It takes unnecessary blocks off the calendar and makes responsibilities and expectations clearer.
Reduced inefficiency.
Designing a 4-day workweek has benefits for employees that increase overall productivity for the company, too. Tap two birds with one stone and finally update and streamline processes while offering teams something they truly want.
Ready to make appreciation an everyday habit?
Try HeyTaco free for 30 days. No credit card required.
Try HeyTaco free
Side-by-side comparison: The 4-day workweek vs. unlimited PTO
| 4-day workweek | Unlimited PTO |
|---|---|
| Works best when it’s a 32-hour week with the same pay, not four 10-hour days | Mainly works when there’s minimum mandatory time off |
| Requires planning and pilots to remove excess tasks | Reduced admin, fewer metrics to track |
| Companies maintain control by adjusting the model (fixed vs. staggered) | Approval highly dependent on managers with different workloads and philosophies |
| Best for teams with excessive meetings that need a time redesign | Best for small, high-trust teams |
| Worst for coverage-dependent roles without sufficient planning | Worst for teams without cultural norms or strong manager relationships |
Case Study: COLAB
Several years ago, Morgan Witham heard about the benefits of a four-day workweek. She eventually decided to explore whether or not this could be a productivity and talent-attractor at her digital agency, COLAB. Witham pitched it to leaders, solicited advice from other CEOs who did it, and started a three-month pilot with defined KPIs.
The financial data was a little off due to additional changes at the company, but it was a hit with employees. The pilot was extended for another few months. Among the main challenges were cutting the week’s hours down to an honest 32 and keeping client deadlines intact.
Ultimately, here are some of the design components that worked:
- Everyone gets the same fixed day off: Friday. Staggering would burden managers. Midweek operations are most important.
- Adjusting days on holiday weeks. Team members may work a Friday if a holiday would otherwise cut into the four-day workweek.
- PTO is based on tenure. You can get either three, four, or five weeks of PTO, bearing in mind that a week is 32 hours.
- Strong client communication. Everyone knows and approves of COLAB’s four-day week. There’s an emergency phone tree, and most Friday emails are answered on Monday.
Ninety-five percent of new hires cite the short workweek as the deciding factor in working at COLAB. Witham doesn’t think it’s the biggest retention lever (that’s still culture), but vastly prefers this model to unlimited PTO.
“The four-day work week is not a substitute for addressing other things that need to be addressed,” she says. “But if you have a very strong culture, a very inclusive team, strong managers that care deeply…when you layer it on…I mean, it's like rocket fuel."
Hear Morgan’s full story for some pretty invaluable insight and particulars on implementing.
Design a better employee experience with both.
HeyTaco puts limits on recognition, giving users five tacos a day. This adds structure to peer recognition. It tells people that five tacos a day is a normal, beneficial amount of appreciation to share in a specific timeframe.
PTO policies become more effective when you apply this principle. The cap is up to you, but make clear that employees must take two or three weeks off this year. This establishes the norm. It takes companies from sounding generous to actually being generous.
And if you can swing a four-day workweek? Even better. Real weekly recovery, real vacations, and real, daily recognition.
FAQ: 4-day workweek vs. unlimited PTO
Why do people take less time off with unlimited PTO?
Because there’s no established norm to conform to. If everyone has 20 days of PTO, that establishes a clear limit. With unlimited PTO, you don’t know if 10 days is the most you can take without looking lazy.
How do you implement a 4-day work week?
Start with a brief operational study to find out what can go, such as extra meetings or busywork. From there, pick the model (staggered or same days) and announce a pilot. A three-month trial is long enough to measure improvements in output quality, reduced burnout, and heightened engagement.
What's a fair PTO policy for a small company?
A common policy for small teams is 10-15 days plus holidays. It may be more “fair” to offer something like 20-25 days with an MTO of 10-15 days. This is perceived as fair and generous because it encourages people to actually take a solid portion of their allotted PTO. It establishes multiple norms to remove any doubts about the policy.
Is time off a performance strategy?
Yes, that’s exactly what entrepreneur and CEO Martin Gourdeau told us: "Time off is a performance strategy, not a reward." He reasons that AI has increased expectations on human workers, and this dynamic threatens their energy. Would you want a key team member kicking off a huge project amid several months of overwork and no time off? Unlikely.
