Workplace Transparency: How Much Should Leaders Share with Employees?

Data shared in one of Slack’s Future Forum reports states that employees who perceive their employer as transparent have 12 times higher job satisfaction. However, the transparency in question isn’t…

Workplace Transparency: How Much Should Leaders Share with Employees?

Data shared in one of Slack’s Future Forum reports states that employees who perceive their employer as transparent have 12 times higher job satisfaction. 

However, the transparency in question isn’t having their minute-by-minute tracking data shared companywide, down to the latest keystroke. So what does real, beneficial, employee-positive workplace transparency look like? 

TL;DR

  • Leader transparency prevents gossip, builds trust, and can improve performance.
  • Employees aren’t just interested in financials. How decisions are made matters.
  • Speculation and personal information are good examples of what not to share with employees. The latter especially threatens psychological safety.

What are the benefits of workplace transparency?

Uncertainty generates anxiety in all aspects of life. At work, it creates worries that eventually boil down to one of two things: whether we’re doing a good job and whether we will keep our jobs.

Strategic, consistent transparency reduces uncertainty. People have a rough idea of what’s occurring, they trust that it’s the truth, and they know why it’s happening.

Preventing gossip. 

If your people don’t know, some of them will make it up. And they’ll spitball their fill-in-the-blank exercise with coworkers. 

Say leadership goes into a closed meeting for two hours without any explanation. By the time they come out, Slack is alight with theories. You had no idea the CEO is leaving, the biggest client has bailed, and half of everyone is getting laid off. 

Building trust. 

Building trust in teams requires leadership that is both credible and reliable. Plus, people feel they belong because they receive more updates than they do surprises.

Take a team that’s been fully remote for three years. Leadership heavily identifies them as such in core values, job postings, etc. One Monday, everyone gets an email that they have 30 days to return to the office three days a week. How did we end up here?

Making decisions. 

Psychological safety at work begins with being able to speak up and contribute. Not just without fear, but secure in the knowledge that your voice has an impact.

Imagine that a product team has been forthcoming and proactive in presenting potential fixes for an app. Leadership is very engaged in the exchange and says they can all make a decision together next week. Two days later, the team gets a message that they’re rebuilding. Why did they even bother putting together those solutions? 

5 Things to consider sharing with employees

Industry norms, laws, and a lot more impact what we can reasonably share at work. However, there are at least two items on this list that every leader can use to build more trust and safety with employees.

1. Metrics and finances.

Want employees to own their work, present solutions, and maybe even feel compelled to work harder? Treat them like adults and not mere underlings by sharing revenue targets, burn rates, or KPIs. It connects what they do to results.

2. What you don’t know.

The credibility that creates trust isn’t about having the right answer at all times. Stop crafting word salads and say you don’t know right now. It’s the most authentic, low-stakes way to display some vulnerability. 

3. The why behind decisions.

Sometimes you don’t need the wider team to agree or vote on what’s being done. Still, research shows that employees are 4.3 times more likely to trust leaders who share their rationale. As a result, they’ll be more likely to adapt and adopt organizational changes.

4. Lessons and losses.

We talk about celebrating failures a lot in the recognition space. The way to get teams to open up and share those mistakes is to share your own. Even when someone else makes the error, highlight what you learned from it. 

This one tip is a building block of everything that makes a culture strong and team cohesive. People who hide mistakes or project infallibility are pushing human connection away.

✨ Explore

Discover what HeyTaco can do for your team

See how HeyTaco makes peer recognition simple, fun, and impactful.

Explore HeyTaco



5. What’s the plan?

There are plenty of instances where transparency can make everyone more anxious. Tough updates can be accompanied by courses of action, even incomplete ones. Even when the news is neutral, sharing what steps come next puts everyone on the same side.

Case Study Corner: Workplace transparency tips from real leaders Open communication looks different on every team. Over the years, HeyTaco has tackled this topic with some really experienced leaders. Here’s a glimpse at what their approaches include.“I would always open the floor and say, ‘Is there something you've never asked that you think is off limits?’ The worst case is I'll say it's off limits, but ask the question. It doesn't cost anything to ask a question."Martin Gourdeau, engaging employees through transparency“You can reply directly into Office Vibe. Problem is that it will stay as a one-to-one conversation. Maybe the thing that I said is important for 10 other people.”Francesco Vetica, keeping information visible and accessible."Not just saying, ‘I hear you and thank you,’ but ‘I hear you, and here's what I'm going to do about it.’"Katie Regan, sharing plans and providing feedback has impact.


When and where should you practice workplace transparency?

Even the perfect amount of transparency can go ignored or misunderstood. Here are some ideal venues for clear, useful messaging.

  • Town Hall Q&As. This is the time and place to share bigger strategic shifts or anything else requiring companywide alignment. Consider including anonymous tools so newer people and introverts can feel safe asking something bold. 
  • CEO AMAs and office hours. If teams don’t have regular interaction with the CEO, then both sides are probably thinking and working in different bubbles. Try Ask Me Anything sessions in chat and set hours where anyone can approach with questions.
  • Async video. Sometimes distributed teams need nuanced answers. Managers of async teams should be recording video at least once a month to provide this. Tone and body language add to the trustworthiness of transparency, and people shouldn’t need another live meeting to get the read on you.

What NOT to share with employees

We couldn’t leave without discussing boundaries. One thing about leaders who’ve mastered transparency–even to the point of radical transparency–is that they draw a bold line around what’s shared. 

Add these to the list along with NDA-bound info, active litigation, or other sensitive disclosures.

Too much speculation.

This one creeps in despite best intentions. It happens when “I don’t know” is sort of untrue and starts mingling with “I’m figuring it out.” When it comes to weightier topics like restructuring, finances, or layoffs, be sure what you share is reliable and vetted. 

Exercise caution around “thinking out loud” even if the stakes aren’t so high. Your casual guesses can become facts inside of the team. Say a manager interprets a client’s mood as them being ready to split, and wonders about it out loud. Now we have one team member spreading the word, another tacking on the suggestion that the whole team will be cut, and a third already browsing job listings.

“Unprocessed stress.”

This is a sanitary blanket term for anger, sadness, hopelessness, confusion, and other emotions in higher quantities. Transparent leaders don’t vent to employees, but they don’t make excuses or deny their moods, either.

The founder of Bureau of Digital explained this to us once. If it impacts your behavior, tell your people what you’re bringing into the room (“I had an argument with my kid”). That’s it. This way, everyone knows your demeanor isn’t about them. It keeps your emotional state from being a distraction. 


Warning: Oversharing doesn’t create psychological safety at work.The biggest “do not share” of them all is personal, individual information about other employees. This seems like a no-brainer, but it sneaks in when we start working harder to build human connections.In addition to compensation or medical information, consider all personal info you’re told one-on-one by an employee to be private, even if they didn’t say so. An employee who approaches a manager to explain why they might be a little slower than usual (a breakup, loss of a pet, etc.) is easy to relate to and feel empathy for. But attempting to rally support for them by letting anyone else on the team know can feel like a big betrayal. When managers keep it confidential, employees feel more confident working with them.


Be transparent about what you appreciate, too. 

Workplace transparency isn’t all budgets and constructive criticism. It’s the small stuff too, such as not knowing something. Or that small bit of behind-the-scenes feedback that led to a surprising decision. 

Recognition is the same. Project success and championing core values are cause for celebration. However, so are smaller milestones and gestures. Trust, belonging, and collaboration flourish when appreciation is given freely, every day.

"It is a quick and easy way to show recognition and celebrate teammates. Initially, I thought it might be cheesy, but when you are able to acknowledge more wins throughout the organization, they quickly become meaningful."

  • Elaina C., HeyTaco User, Claims Compliance Supervisor

Learn more about recognizing everyday wins with HeyTaco.



HeyTaco

Written by HeyTaco

HeyTaco helps teams build a culture of everyday recognition, turning simple peer-to-peer appreciation into lasting engagement.

This one emoji is changing team culture 🌮

Used by 5,000+ teams since 2016, with 46M+ tacos sent.

Add to Slack